It was quite a busy day yesterday on the My Little Pony Facebook page.  Hasbro announced the release date for the Equestria Girls movie (on DVD this Tuesday!  which makes it the widest release!) as well as the toy line associated with the spin-off.

As I have been tracking since the beginning of the marketing for the spin-off (starting here, then here, and here), there has been a lot of displeasure among the professed fandom of bronies, to both the movie and the toys.  The amount of in-fandom fighting has been particularly keen on the representation of the ponies as quasi-humans, and the new toy line only drives home the pony/human hybrid that has been created by Hasbro.  The criticisms range from anorexic to sell-outs to disingenuous — with very little voiced reflection as to whom the toys are actually meant.  (Hint: it is not the bronies.)


But I was still taken aback by how many people were voicing there displeasure over the toys.  In 14 hours since the image of the toys was released on the Facebook page, the posting has generated 1400 comments.  That is the most of all the marketing information I have seen released on Facebook — especially when the amount is compared to the time length in which they could have commented.  And many are commenting by using memes that reflect their displeasure and disbelief over the toys.

What is fascinating here is not so much that the people are reacting this way — well, no, I take that back.  It is the reason this is fascinating: here we have adults from around the world responding to a toy as if it was meant for their consumption when in fact it was not.

Does Hasbro really care what the bronies think as long as the children buy the toys and the movie?

Hasbro may dislike having their Facebook comments sections become these virtual forums of vitriol, but very little of this is probably reaching the target audience for MLP:FIM, since few parents allow their young children to have Facebook accounts.  And, as other companies have learned, it is best to allow loyal consumers, aka fans, the place to vent in social media, or else that vitriol could really backlash against the company.

I would really like to talk to any of the Hasbro marketing team, to understand their perception of the bronies and the bronies’ reaction to Equestria Girls.  Is Hasbro intentionally creating these virtual forums?  Do they have the Facebook page more for the bronies than the target audiences?  Have they actually been that strategic in their marketing activities, or are they just going along with the idea that social media is good for marketing, and are not considering the fractured fandom that is their market?

7 responses to “Equestria Girls: Displeasure Among Bronies”

  1. ParaspriteHugger Avatar

    Try some research next time: August 6th is the release date for the DVD. The movie was in theatres since June 16th.


    1. CarrieLynn D. Reinhard Avatar

      I am aware of that — my earlier posts reflect my awareness of that. But since it was on a very limited release, the release of the DVD is a better release of the movie than the theatre release. But good catch, so I made the edit as need be.


      1. ParaspriteHugger Avatar

        Right – when you said the movie probably was for Furries.


      2. CarrieLynn D. Reinhard Avatar

        I suggested the possibility that Hasbro was aware of that subset. Not that it was probably for them. Clearly the movie was intended for young girls.


  2. Equestria Girls: A Reaction to the Film | Playing, With Research Avatar

    […] a summer spent learning about, reading about, and writing about it, I finally tonight sat down and watched My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Equestria Girls. […]


  3. Fractured Fandom | Playing, With Research Avatar

    […] Bin Review.  Given the importance of the concept, fractured fandom, to my work on Doctor Who and My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, I am bringing the specific elements from the article […]


  4. Everypony is Somepony | Playing, With Research Avatar

    […] April is going to be all My Little Pony all the time, as I present my research on the fractured MLP:FIM fandom over the Equestria Girls movie.  A long time ago — a year before the movie […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: